Vancouver Housing Prices are NOT caused by foreigners

A recent article titled "Vancouver housing prices tied to China’s economic growth", Barbara Yaffe quoted two "experts" (David Ley and Robin Wiebe) who will tell anyone who will listen that "housing prices here [in Vancouver] are tied inextricably to purchase activity by foreign buyers." You'll find the use of words like "coincide," "relationship," and "exceptional correlation" between 1) periods of faster growth in China and growth of Vancouver's housing market, 2) house sales and housing starts and GDP growth in China, and 3) international immigration to Vancouver and the city's property prices. Nowhere do we see the words "cause" or "leads to."

Correlation is mostly meaningless, especially when you're using it in the way that David Ley does (see Figure 5.8). One commenter says:

I work at the same institution as Professor Ley, but still I must critique the "evidence" presented in the graph. Perhaps there is more elsewhere in the study, but Figure 5.8 does not provide evidence of anything.
A correlation of 0.94 or 94% looks impressive, but those who know statistics will understand that in the analysis of time-series data, one cannot just correlate the level of something (house prices) and the level of something else (immigration). It is very easy to get very high correlations. Don't believe me. Just try computing the correlation of the house prices with your age. I did. Guess what--the correlation is 94.5%. Evidently, my age predicts Vancouver house prices better than net immigration. Obviously, you can put in anyone's age and the result would be the same.

You can see more examples of ridiculous correlations at spurious correlations, like "US spending on science, space, and technology correlates with suicides by hanging, strangulation and suffocation" (0.992) and "Divorce rate in Maine correlates with Per capita consumption of margarine" (0.993).

Repeat after me: correlation does not imply causation.

Also lacking in the Yaffe article was any serious discussion of the more obvious causes of housing price increases, such as interest rates, 0% down mortgages and 40 year amortizations in the mid 2000s, and the effect of CMHC default insurance. These all have a real effect on housing prices. There was a singling out of Vancouver, and no discussion of all the other Canadian cities that have experienced similar relative price increases, and no mention of all the non-foreign buyers owning multiple condos (and renting them for very little profit), thus speculating on price increases on the value of the home.

The effect that interest rates have is huge. The Bank of Canada bank rate was 6% at it's peak of the tech bubble (2000)! then the tech bubble burst and the Bank of Canada started slashing the interest rates to as low as 0.5% (2009); a swing of 5.5%! The bank variable rates are a bit more than that, I'm getting 2.2% which is about the lowest they've ever gone. So let's say 2% and 7.5% for a spread of 5.5%. To make things even crazier, throw in the 40 year mortgage which was available for a little while:

Effect of amortization period and interest rate for a $500,000 home:
$3650 monthly payment (at 7% for 25 years)
$1500 monthly payment (at 2% for 40 years)

That's with no change to down payments. Add in the effect of lower down payments (increased leveraging) due to lower requirements + CMHC default insurance, people owning multiple properties (more leveraging and speculation), and people buying more house than they can afford (if interest rates increased but they assume house value will only go up), and you have a recipe for the bubble we have today.

Finally, Vancouver has experienced the same growth in housing prices that the rest of Canada has.

All figures below are from http://www.housepriceindex.ca (which actually measures same house sale pairs over time, not just "average home prices"). I downloaded the spreadsheet and calculated the total percentage increase in the index from early 1999 (data is spotty before then, some cities go back to 1990, others don't).

Winnipeg 305%
Edmonton 290%
Quebec City 285%
Vancouver 276%
Calgary 272%
Montreal 259%
Toronto 242%
Victoria 231%
Hamilton 229%
Ottawa 225%
Halifax 217%

So is the "foreigner effect" happening everywhere in Canada? Or maybe the increases are due to something other than foreigners? During a bubble people are often quoted as saying "it's different this time" or "it's different here." They always end up being wrong.

Tags: 

Comments

Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.
fashion

Much obliged for the tips and info that you provide above, it is very useful for me..i truly value it.
Zobello - The Online Men's Fashion Store
online clothes shopping | online shopping fashion | online dress shopping | online shopping clothes | online shopping clothes | clothes shopping online | online shopping for clothes | shopping online clothes | clothing shopping sites | clothing online shopping | Blezer for man | blazers for men | casual blazers for men | men blazers | buy blazers online |
blazer online shopping | blazers for men online | casual blazer | blazers online india mens casual blazer | blazers for men online | blazers for mens | Swimwear for men | swimwear online india | buy swimwear online india | swimwear india | swimwear online | beachwear india | buy swimwear online | beachwear online | beachwear online india | buy swimwear online | swim shorts for men | swimming trunks online | swimsuit india | buy swimsuit online | canvas shoes for men | sneakers shoes | sneakers for men | sneakers shoes for men | sneaker shoes | buy sneakers online | best sneakers for men | sneakers shoes online | canvas sneakers | high ankle sneakers online india | high ankle shoes online | sneakers shoes online | backpacks for men | backpacks online | backpack bags | backpack online | buy backpacks online | backpacks online india | backpack online india | buy backpacks online india | backpacks india | backpack india | cheap backpacks online india | messenger bags for men | messenger bag | leather messenger bags for men | messenger bags for men india | messenger bags online shopping india | messenger bags india | messenger bags online india | messenger bags for men india | messenger bag online india | messenger bag india | Duffle bags online | duffle bags for men | duffle bags online india | duffel bags online | duffle bag online | duffle bags online india | leather duffle bag india | leather duffle bags online india | duffel bag online | buy duffle bag online | bags online india | online bag shopping | online bags shopping | online shopping bags | bags online shopping india | bags online | online bags | bags online shopping | buy bags online | buy laptop bags online

Yes i am completely concurred with this article and i simply need say this article is exceptionally pleasant and extremely useful article.I will make a point to be perusing your blog more. You made a decent point yet I can't resist the urge to ponder, shouldn't something be said about the other side? !!!!!!THANKS!!!!!! packers and movers hadapsar pune

First of all Iwoould like to say terrific
blog! I had a quick question which I'd like to ask if you don't mind.
I was curious to know hhow you center ourself aand cleaqr your head before writing.
I have had trouble clearing my mind in getting my
ideas out there. I do take pleasure in writing but
it just seems like the first 10 tto 15 minutes are lost sikply
just trying too figure out how tto begin. Any
ideas or tips? Appreciate it!

Feel fre to surf to my homepage :: ζωδια και σχεσεις

I respect this article for the all around looked into substance and magnificent wording. I got so included in this material that I couldn't quit perusing. I am awed with your work and expertise. Much thanks to you to such an extent. read this

I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
vouchers

What i do not understood is if truth be told how you're now noot really much more well-preferred
than you might be now. Youu are very intelligent. You already
know thus significantly in terms of this
matter, produced me for mmy part consider it
from sso many varied angles. Its likee women and men aren't interested unless it
is something to do with Woman gaga! Your own stuffs outstanding.
All the time take care of it up!

Feel free to visit myy webpage ζωδια και σχεσεις

I am extremely delighted in for this web journal. Its a useful subject. It help me all that much to take care of a few issues. Its chance are so awesome and working style so rapid. as an example

"Boredom is a killer—which is why a cure for boredom can be a lifesaver.

The truth is, portable Bluetooth speakers have been the handheld solution to elevate the moment, whether at the beach, the middle of a party, or a lazy afternoon at home for years now—and your brand can get in on that excitement.

Right now—with C2BPromo.com, you can put you logo on a wide array of Promotional Bluetooth Speakers, in all different shapes and sizes, from waterproof to resilient wood—with models coming in at 6-7 dollars all the way up to high-end luxury designs. Multiple surfaces on almost every customized Bluetooth speaker can showcase your logo—so no matter which way it’s turned, your name is always center staged." Promotional Speaker

Nowadays the housing prices have been increased to a great extent. But this is not caused due to the activity of the foreigners. The rate of income has been increased that gradually increased the housing prices due to which people find it very difficult to have a basic living.
prefabricated homes

In my country we can see a very important housing prices increasment, certainly not due to foreigners because they have no money. The fact is nobody can pay these prices, so houses are just empty waiting for the prices go down. Of course, selling house can still be helped with a nice advertising program : agence web dijon

I truly welcome you for this brilliant post that you have accommodated us. I might want to thank you for the endeavors you have made in composing this article. Assignment Land

I genuinely welcome you for this incredible post that you have obliged us. Nowadays the hotel costs have been extended in light of present circumstances. In any case, this is not caused as a result of the activity of the nonnatives. I might need to thank you for the attempts you have made in forming this article. www.proessay.co.uk

Add new comment